HOME| LAMPS | SUBWAYS & TRAINS | ADS | TROLLEYS | SIGNS | COBBLESTONES | STREET SCENES | YOU'D NEVER BELIEVE YOU'RE IN NYC | LINKS | ALLEYS | NECROLOGY | CEMETERIES | NEIGHBORHOODS | FORGOTTENTOURS | SEARCH | FORGOTTENBOOK DIARY | FORGOTTENSTUFF | QUEENS CRAP

FORGOTTEN NEW YORK
HarperCollins,
ORDER from Amazon: paperback or hardcover

YOUR WEBMASTER: Kevin Walsh
CORRESPONDENTS: Christina Wilkinson, Gary Fonville

ABOUT YOUR WEBMASTER

FORGOTTEN NEW YORK T-SHIRTS and more!
Atlantic Avenue runs from the Brooklyn waterfront at the East River to the Van Wyck Expressway in Jamaica, Queens; along the way it separates several neighborhoods and comprises many architectural styles. As downtown Brooklyn remakes itself, the FNY camera caught it on the cusp of what could be major change along its westernmost three miles. Perhaps Atlantic Avenue may not look quite like this ever again...

WAYFARING: Atlantic Avenue

There are seemingly two Atlantic Avenues. There's the one west of Flatbush Avenue, with its small restaurants, antique shops, and Middle Eastern enclave. There's also the one east of Flatbush, with its humongous retail stores, railyards, and further east, auto parts and restaurant supplies retailers. The element that ties each together is the presence of roaring traffic, and motorists use its relatively large width and synchronized traffic lights to get to the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, which marks its western end. Your webmaster recently walked Atlantic's western few miles on the first hot day in May. I had scoured chez webmaster for my copy of the Atlantic Avenue Betterment Association's walking guide, but as so often happens when I really need anything, it was nowhere to be found. So, I downloaded the PDF version and jotted down the locales I wanted to check out, walked and snapped, and here's the webpage.

The western end of Atlantic Avenue empties into the Port Authority's Brooklyn Marine Terminal, one of its three cargo terminals in the city along with the Red Hook Container Terminal in Brooklyn and Staten Island's Howland Hook Terminal. From 1836-1933, this was the site of a passenger ferry to Whitehall Street and South Ferry in Manhattan. For a brief period, 1844 to 1859, the Long Island Rail Road delivered passengers here via a tunnel under the avenue -- which is still in place.

Furman Street runs along the Brooklyn waterfront from Atlantic Avenue to Old Fulton Street. It once lay at the bottom of a steep hill; the presence of the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, which has run on top of it since the 1950s, somewhat camouflages the hill. Once the province of waterfront industry, including a pocket railroad, Furman Street may become the site of a renaissance as new residences and perhaps an extended Brooklyn Bridge Park are set to be built along its western edge. In the hopefully named One Brooklyn Bridge Park, above, some folks will have a great view of Manhattan, but some, it seems, better get ready to gulp car exhaust.

The BQE curves here to hug the waterfront, and it does so because Brooklyn Heights residents were successful in persuading "master builder" Robert Moses to detour the expressway and not cut through most of the Heights' historic houses and quiet streets. As is, the BQE was cut through in 1954. Residents of the Bronx' Castle Hill and Unionport neighborhoods, and Brooklyn's Cobble Hill weren't so lucky, however, as those locales could not stop the Moses juggernaut in the Fab Fifties.
What was 55 Atlantic Avenue is presently the northbound entrance to the BQE. In 1883 Irish immigrant Benjamin Moore opened a paint factory here. A few years later, the company moved to Newark, NJ and is presently based in Montvale, NJ.

Until February 20, 1949, the B32 trolley line ran along 5th and Atlantic Avenues to its terminus at the East River. Pretty much the only remnant left is this lone trolley wire pole at the BQE entrance and Atlantic Avenue, which is handy dandy to hang traffic signs on.

Montero Bar and Grill, 73 Atlantic, has been part of the Atlantic Avenue scene since 1940. It relocated to 73 Atlantic from 56 in 1947 after the BQE condemned its first locale.

Every single inch of Montero Bar and Grill is crowded with stuff, mostly gifts that sailors and seamen brought the original owner, Joseph Montero, since he opened here in 1947. Some of it dates from even earlier, when his bar was across the street. Thirty-four ship models, dozens of shipping prints and a veritable family album of the Montero family's lives are just a sample of the items hanging from the walls and packing the alcoves. But this is not a museum: it is a living, breathing bar. It has remained raffish and even a little intimidating as the neighborhood around it has grown wealthy and precious. Wendell Jamieson, "A Raffish Reminder, Landlubbers, of Saltier Days," NYTimes, May 9, 2003

A bit of past nomenclature can be seen at the NW corner building, 75 Atlantic, at Hicks Street near Montero's: Atlantic Avenue was Atlantic Street. In the 1700s, the avenue was a path to Ralph Patchen's farm at the East River waterfront (Ralph and Patchen are now Bedford-Stuyvesant avenues); by 1816 it had become District Street; by 1855, Atlantic Street. In a year either side of 1870, it had become Atlantic Avenue--by then Long Island Rail Road tracks extended east to Jamaica and the right-of-way assumed its name. So, this building is quite old; it goes back to at least 1870.

"Rock & roll cocktail lounge" Magnetic Field at 97 brought live music to Atlantic Avenue in the early 2000s. My friend Dawn, a Sixties music devotee, has been a patron.

Floral Heights had an offer. Your webmaster, whose name is Kevin Jude, was out of luck.

Dead Know Brooklyn

Florists and funeral homes are never far apart. Cronin, now Heights and Hill, was instituted by Irish immigrant Jere Cronin in 1896 at 103 and later moved to 115. The Cronin legacy is marked by the big C at the roofline.

Few Brooklynites prefer to admit it but Brooklyn is indeed the western end of Long Island. Long Island University still acknowledges this, but the Long Island Historical Society long ago became the Brooklyn Historical Society. And then there's the Long Island Restaurant, 110 Atlantic, at the SE corner of Atlantic Avenue and Henry Street.

Emma Sullivan says the food in the Long Island Restaurant is exactly as it was when her father, Ramon Montero, opened up in 1951 -- hamburgers (onions raw or fried), meatloaf, chicken soup, fresh-cut French fries -- and eating it, you believe her. Why bother changing the recipes when everything tastes so good? The Art Deco bar back has been so well cared for that it looks brand-new, the wood and the two lighted columns in the middle polished so religiously that they shine. Wendell Jamieson, "The Quarrel," NY Times, March 6, 2006 $$$

The two in-law matriarchs of Montero's and the Long Island Restaurant have feuded for years, as the above article explains. It's unfortunate.

Neither Bennett nor Pink

Smith Street's reinvigoration as a restaurant and bistro mecca has radiated to surrounding environs, including Atlantic Avenue, which has seen its share of eclectic joints spring up in the last few years (as of 2007).

Atlantic Chip Shop, 129 Atlantic: A small bar counter adjacent to the bar seats a handful, and to the rear, a dozen+ roundie and square tables done with small glass candles to ‘em, and sharing common benches on the walls; one of red brick and the other in pressed tin, same as the ceiling. Drop cone glass lamps over the bar & bullet lamps throughout. British car signage adorns the walls, as do framed pics of the Beatles & John Lennon, a Quadrophenia movie poster, a London underground print, Who, Clash & Beatles posters, London Bridge pics, etc. A lip over the rear rear nook of the place holds plates, trays and tea set pieces. 16 taps on a single tower on the bar...Traditional English fare. [Beer Advocate]

Floyd NY, next door at 131, immediately drew attention when it opened in 2004, due largely to its indoor bocce court. Besides teaching people to bowl again, Floyd NY provides a comfortable wide-open space to relax. One bartender describes the space as "Rustic; raw but stylish." He attributes a lot of the appeal to the size of the space, formerly two storefronts. Despite all its space, the bar is often full. Usually bustling, the crowds vary from night to night. The 8 tap beers are good, if common selections. [Brooklyn Record, which also reviews other new Atlantic Avenue bars]

124-128 Atlantic, above, was formerly the Atlantic-Pacific Chandlery Manufacturing Company (a chandler stocks ships for ocean voyages). The old name is perserved as the Atlantic-Pacific Building. 130 Atlantic, right, was formerly home to Citizens' Gas, which, after some mergers and several renamings, is today's KeySpan.

Pete's Waterfront Ale House, 155 Atlantic, was formerly the Congregation Baith Israel Anshei Emes, but the synagogue hasn't been here since 1862. It is presently located a few blocks away on Kane Street.

They have a great selection of beers, both bottled and draft, and they rotate the selections often enough so that you can always find something new and interesting to try, everything from Ebulum Elderberry Black Ale from Scotland (the last time I was there) to local favorites from Brooklyn Brewery. If you aren't sure what you want just ask one of the bartenders. They tend to be pretty knowledgeable about the offerings. [1000 Bars]

The slogan "warm beer, lousy food" seems to have been lifted from the old Crazy Country Club, though.

The impressive SE corner building at Clinton Street, 160 Atlantic Avenue. Note that the window styles are different on each of the building's top four floors.
Atlantic Avenue can boast a couple of Deco palaces, including 200 Clinton Street. It was built in 1926 and closely resembles the building it replaced, The Fougera, named for its Victorian-era builder, Edmond Fougera.

Ghostly Gentleman

Your webmaster took a brief detour, or rather a pilgrimage, to 169 Clinton, at State Street a block north of Atlantic Avenue. Here on the first floor for most of 1925 lived master macabre fictionist H.P. Lovecraft (1890-1937). Closely associated with Providence, RI, his home for most of his life, Lovecraft moved to a one-floor apartment here in what was then a depressed part of Brooklyn after his wife, Sonia, moved to Cincinnati, OH to find work in a department store. Lovecraft was unhappy in Brooklyn, and moved back to Providence in 1926 as his marriage foundered.

In his 1996 biography H.P. Lovecraft: A Life, S. T. Joshi relates:

...Lovecraft found disappointing, at least initially ... the seediness of the general area; but he knew that beggars could not be choosers. ...

...The room at 169 Clinton Street really was rather seedy --in a run down neighborhood, with a dubious clientele, and infested with mice. For this last problem Lovecraft purchased 5¢ mousetraps "since I could throw them away without removing the corpus delecti, a thing I should hate to do with a costlier bit of mechanism."

Most of his suits were robbed during his stay, the only thing he had in the apartment beside his books worth stealing. His stories He and The Horror At Red Hook, neither of which present NYC in a favorable light, were written during this period.

My coming to New York had been a mistake; for whereas I had looked for poignant wonder and inspiration in the teeming labyrinths of ancient streets that twist endlessly from forgotten courts and squares and waterfronts to courts and squares and waterfronts equally forgotten, and in the Cyclopean modern towers and pinnacles that rise blackly Babylonian under waning moons, I had found instead only a sense of horror and oppression which threatened to master, paralyze, and annihilate me. --Lovecraft, from "He"

164-168 Atlantic Avenue, built between 1860 and 1868 (NOT 1859 as the chiseled sign says), is described thusly in the AIA Guide to New York City:

Merchant princes of the 19th Century were more concerned with the quality of their architecture than those of the 20th...

[As Desmond from the mid-2000s hit TV show Lost might say, "Amen, brutha!"]

...Note the stone quoins and bracketed roof cornices.

The painted sign, by the way, is not an 1860 original:

In the mid-to-late 1800s, when New York's ports were the world's busiest, a number shipbuilders, sail makers and other nautical tradesman in Manhattan and Brooklyn thrived. There is physical evidence of the nautical trade at 164-168 Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, where Two Trees Realty restored the facade of an old sail loft, while converting it to luxury apartments. While those days are long gone, it doesn't mean that you still can't find a skilled pro who knows how to craft a sail in New York City. [Sail Brooklyn]

East to Atlantic

More and more glass bus shelters are appearing around town, like this one at Atlantic and Clinton. How these will survive the expected graffiti and vandalism -- New Yorkers smash bus shelters with sledgehammers and baseball bats -- is a mystery to your webmaster, but this one looks fine for now.

Yemen Café, 176 Atlantic, along with Sahadi's (see below) is one of t he linchpins of Atlantic Avenue's Middle Eastern community. 176 was an early photo studio in the1860s.

Some of the shops on Atlantic Avenue have been selling Middle Eastern goods for 100 years, ever since large numbers of "Syrians" - many of whom came from what is today Lebanon, Iraq or Jordan - first started arriving in the United States. By the turn of the century, about 100 Arab families were clustered near the end of the avenue by the waterfront, a satellite of the main "Little Syria" on Washington Street in lower Manhattan. They enjoyed a rich cultural life that was in many ways like the one in the old country, with Arabic newspapers, coffee houses and festivals where they danced the old dances. In those days, some of the young men journeyed back home to fetch brides.

For many of the children and grandchildren of the immigrants living on or near Atlantic Avenue, its shops and restaurants were their only tangible link to the old country. Helen Uniss Khouri, for instance, was born in Brooklyn into a distinguished family from Abeye on the eve of World War I; she did not travel to Lebanon until the late 1940's, and her sister Katherine Uniss Haddad never did get to go. As children, all of their images of the homeland were filtered through the memories of their elders or reflected in the transplanted life of the avenue.
[Saudi Aramco World]

Sahadi, 187-189, is the largest and most famous Middle Eastern food store on Atlantic Avenue, opening here in 1948. The business was instituted in 1895 by Abraham Sahadi on Washington Street in lower Manhattan. Unusually it occupies the ground floor of two separate buildings.

The intersection of Atlantic Avenue and Court Street isn't unusual, except that the manhole (seen faintly below the rear tire of the black car) is the only known entrance to the LIRR tunnel under the avenue.

Sahadi: After you get through the ridiculous room of bulk spices, nuts, and coffee that makes you feel like you’re in Morocco, you reach the unbelievable deli, where everything is oily and beautiful and cheap. As we waited in the seemingly interminable line, little women kept coming out of the back bearing steaming trays of gorgeous food. We feasted on several of these phyllo-wrapped tidbits (mushroom and eggplant ...and spanakopita... we also had a wonderful tomato and feta version, as well as one with potato and herbs). Each item cost slightly more than a dollar, and we were stuffed and happy after sitting on a Brooklyn Heights stoop and eating every shred of dough and filling. [Eat]

Latterly a branch of Independence Bank, this Classical bank building, 130 Court at Atlantic, was constructed in 1922 by McKenzie, Voorhees and Gmelin as a branch of the South Brooklyn Savings Institution.

Cobble Hill and Red Hook have been known as South Brooklyn for the better part of two centuries, since at one time they were indeed the southern reaches of the City of Brooklyn. As the 19th Century rolled on Brooklyn annexed towns to its south and east, until it was co-terminous with Kings County. Brooklyn enjoyed this exalted status for only a few years until it too was annexed in 1898 by a bigger city to its west...New York City.

John DeCesare produced the bronze plaque that commemorates what is thought to be the redoubt where George Washington observed the Battle of Brooklyn in August 1776, a battle that the patriots lost. It amounted to a glorious retreat when 400 Maryland troops interrupted the British before they could finish off Lord Stirling's troops. Most of the Marylanders paid with their lives, but the patriots lived to fight another day.

St. Clair Restaurant, at 93 Smith Street, has been here since 1920 according to a sign on its awning. That means it preceded Smith Street's restaurant redux by a good 75 years.

A jail with retail? The Brooklyn House of Detention at Atlantic Avenue and Boerum Place may become just that! 3-sides of the prison's ground floor may be converted to 24,000 feet of retail space. Would you shop there? Paul Von Zielbauer, The Brooklyn House of Detention, Seen as a Jail With Retail, $$$, NYTimes, March 10, 2006

The prison was constructed in 1957 (as was your webmaster), replacing Miller's Furniture Store.

The Boerum family arrived from Holland in the 1600s and produced prominent landholders and politicians in the colonial era. At Atlantic Avenue, Boerum switches from a narrow lane to an 8-lane behemoth also called Brooklyn Bridge Boulevard.

The Smith, a 12-story luxury condo building/boutique hotel, arises at 75 Smith on the NE corner of Atlantic. Its 12 stories make it about eight taller than the biggest of the surrounding buildings. If you have ever wondered what its architect, Nick Dine, looks like, there he is. On the Smith Street side, you would have a great view of the prison.

George Treiss Jewelry, 308 Atlantic, now law offices. How have those wood block letters survived over 135 years?
Some of Atlantic Avenue's gritty reality will be obvious to residents of The Smith if they face the Atlantic Avenue side, where there are a string of bail bonds offices serving the Brooklyn House of Detention.
The fine glass-faced Art Deco building at 320 Atlantic Avenue was a National Cash Register office from 1930-47.

A bit of old-skool Atlantic at 307-309, home of Academy Rubber Stamp. It's a shame that businesses whose products -- like the stamps, notary materials, business cards, etc. made by Academy -- manufactred and sold in NYC seem to be disappearing in favor of Starbucks and banks, banks, banks.

A typical Brooklyn scene, at Atlantic Avenue and Hoyt Street, now includes construction cranes.
Mural, Brawta Caribbean Café, 347 Atlantic Avenue

Atlantic Avenue flips again at Hoyt; for the next two blocks, many of the businesses have been, for the better part of 3 decades, antique retailers and restorers. Other furnishing stores are here too, carpet stores and reupholsterers.

Note the "Florence" inscription at the top of the building at right.

Downtown Atlantic, 364. I know I want one but my doctor doesn't want me to have one, and most of the women I know don't want me to have one.

It looks like a synagogue but Talmud Torah Beth Jacob Joseph, a school at 368, moved out long ago and the 1917 space is now Time Trader Antiques.

It looks older than it is, but the Belorussian Autocephalic Orthodox Church, at 401 Atlantic and Bond Street has been here "only" since 1902. St. Peter's Episcopal Church erected a building here in 1850, and subsequently sold it to the Second United Presbyterian Church in 1863, who constructed this Gothic church in 1902.

Stan's Place at 411 promises authentic New Orleans and Cajun fare. The exterior, at least, is New Orleans-style.
House of the Lord Church, 415 Atlantic. Pastor Herbert Daughtry has been involved in a myriad of causes over the years, such as the slaughter in Darfur, Sudan. This was originally the Swedish Pilgrims' Evangelical Church built in 1903.

Relieved

Ex-Lax, the "chocolated laxative" was founded in 1908 by Lithuanian immigrant Israel Matz. The constipation relief medicine was, in 2007, produced by Novartis.

Its 1925 Atlantic Avenue factory, 423-443, was converted to 57 co-operative apartments in 1981, making it somewhat of an Atlantic Avenue pioneer.

Part of the Ex-Lax complex since 1925, 435-443 Atlantic was the August Busch Bottling Company from 1893-1903. Budweiser, introduced in 1876, was bottled here.

It's been a blank brick wall for a few years now, but this building at Atlantic and Nevins Street was for a couple of decades, the canvas of satirical wall dog Jerry Johnson...

Jerry Johnson's last poster.

Jerry Johnson has been painting ironic murals on a building at the corner of Atlantic Avenue and Nevins Street in the Boerum Bill section of Brooklyn since 1982. His first depicted a 1940's trio in snazzy attire lounging beside a shiny car, accompanied by the admonishment "Dress right . . . and get a better shake out of life." Smaller lettering informed the viewer that the message was "Courtesy of the President's Council on Appearances."

Completed during Ronald Reagan's
first term in office, it juggled ideas about dressing for success and right-wing politics. "Cash," a 1987 work in which a glassy-eyed woman is shown dreaming of dollar signs and consumer goods, poked fun at the plummeting status of bills and coins in an age of plastic money. In "Plates," from 1985, a chef proffers an egg on a plate. lt is a simple gesture that manages to be political, making points about synthetic food and polystyrene containers.

"I started doing these billboards because l had something to say, other than what l said from 9 to 5," the artist explains. "I thought, `why not use the existing medium and language in its most classic format to address some of the things going on today?' Billboards are honest. I have real problems with the art world, where someone can paint a painting that makes a condemnatory statement about capitalism and sell it for $80,000. The artist gets rich and the patron sits on the painting until it appreciates, then dumps it. It's so hypocritical, it's ludicrous." Mark Dery, "The Merry Pranksters And the Art of the Hoax"

S.W. Cornell opned a hardware store at 121-125 Court Street in 1853 and purchased a new 3-story building at 475 Atlantic in 1927. In signs like this the first year refers to the founding of the company, and the second number is the year the current building was built. For many years 475 Atlantic was home to the Kalfaian Carpet Warehouse; it's presently a kids' martial arts center.

The Muhlenberg Residence, located at 510-514 Atlantic Avenue is a 201-unit dwelling for low income, homeless, housing needy, and community people. Lutheran Social Services, an experienced social service provider and housing manager, rehabilitated the building with assistance from HPD's Supportive Housing Loan Program. NYC.gov

The Muhlenberg for most of its life was the Times Plaza Hotel, named, like Times Plaza itself at Atlantic and Flatbush Avenues for a former Brooklyn newspaper. Its 1930s Art Deco touches are still apparent.

City Lights Diner, formerly Steve's Restaurant, SE corner of Atlantic and 3rd Avenues. Have a look inside.

The Young Women's Christian Association built this edifice at 3rd and Atlantic in 1927. Boys were invited in for socials, etc. beginning in 1943.

Hank's Saloon, 46 3rd Avenue at Atlantic -- By day, it’s a rough-looking, rundown, flame-painted biker bar with a craggy cast of regulars that could scare Bukowski straight. But by night… well, actually, it’s about the same, but with more people, and live music. Every Sunday (Sunday! Sunday!) night, house band Sean Kershaw and the New Jack Ramblers belch out upbeat country classics to a backdrop of free hamburgers, dancin’ cuties, and random insanity, while the Lovely and Talented Daria dishes out $2 beer to Brooklyn’s most nefarious assortment of country-lovin’ drunks. Don’t let the honky sounds fool you—this place attracts all kinds: white, black, old, young, punk, bluegrass, crazy and crazier.

One recent Sunday night at Hank’s, I saw pair of local b-boys get down on the floor and breakdance to an old-time honky-tonk jam while nubile hipster girls guzzled cans of Pabst through a beer bong. It don’t get any more mixed-up—or better—than this, folks. After Sunday, you’re on your own, as, depending on the time and night, the place is either hopping with live rock bands or takes on a decidedly Tourette Syndrome vibe. [Brooklyn Country]

The Times Plaza Station, US Post Office, was built in 1925. The upper floors used to house Local 361 of the Ironworkers Union, many of whose members were Mohawk Indians living nearby.

It's been said that the Williamsburg Bank Building is the most priapic in NYC. Your webmaster won't go the obvious route with this picture...I'll just say it looks like it's giving us the finger. Formerly the House of Pain, its dentists and oral surgeons have mostly moved out to make way for mucho $$$ condos.

552-554 Atlantic, the Masjid Al-Farooq mosque and Al-Aqusa Islamic School, has been likened to a "glazed candy cane." This section of Atlantic is intensely Arabic.

Had enough Atlantic Avenue? Your webmaster hadn't. Continue on to Part 2.

HOME| LAMPS | SUBWAYS & TRAINS | ADS | TROLLEYS | SIGNS | COBBLESTONES | STREET SCENES | YOU'D NEVER BELIEVE YOU'RE IN NYC | LINKS | ALLEYS | NECROLOGY | CEMETERIES | NEIGHBORHOODS | FORGOTTENTOURS | SEARCH | FORGOTTENBOOK DIARY | FORGOTTENSTUFF | QUEENS CRAP

erpietri@earthlink.net

©2007