
ROSEBANK, a neighborhood on Staten Island’s eastern shore located north of Fort Wadsworth, has been anchored by the campanile of St. Mary’s Roman Catholic Church since 1857 at 1101 Bay Street at St. Mary’s Avenue, and the slim spire of St. John’s Episcopal Church built in 1871 at 1331 Bay opposite Belair Road. Rosebank, primarily an Italian neighborhood in the early 21st Century, has been home to pioneering photographer Alice Austen and Italian unifier Giuseppe Garibaldi.
In 2020, St. Mary’s (shown here in March 2025) was desanctified as the result of poor patronage. The parish merged with St. Joseph’s R.C. Church in Rosebank and Immaculate Conception R.C. Church in Stapleton. Masses and other liturgical ceremonies are no longer held in the building and all sacred objects, such as altars and baptisimal fonts, had to be removed. Unlike St. John’s down the block, the building isn’t under Landmarks protection. The building has been unused since 2015.
Sadly, another use for the building isn’t in the cards and since August 2026, it is in a slow process of demolition. This week, the bell tower was dismantled, with the rest of the building to follow.
It’s been a bad year for NYC’s classic churches. In April, Astoria Village lost its Dutch Reformed Church (1888) to a fire, and Williamsburg’s South Bushwick Reformed followed suit. In Bay Ridge, Visitation Academy closed its doors in 2024 and sold to developers’ this week, a large demonstration was held at the site calling for its addition to the Landmarks Preservation Commission rolls. Protests of this type are usually futile, as two decades ago St. Saviour’s Church in Maspeth was dismantled and is now the site of warehouses (at least the church can be reassembled in a site yet to be determined).
What will replace St. Mary’s? Routine multifamily boxes, most likely.
Check out the ForgottenBook (HarperCollins, 2006), as well as Forgotten Queens (Arcadia, 2013). I also have a chapter in the anthology “New York Calling: From Blackout to Bloomberg” (Reaktion, 2007). As always, “comment…as you see fit.” I earn a small payment when you click on any ad on the site, which helps in site upkeep and also aids Greater Astoria Historical Society.
11/17/26
