MIDAFTERNOON shadows make it tough to get a good picture of the old St. Ann’s Parochial School on East 11th Street between 3rd and 4th Avenues. One of two reminders of the now-defunct At. Ann’s Roman Catholic parish, founded in 1853, can be seen here on East 11th between 4th and 3rd. St. Ann’s School was a no nonsense brick structure built in 1870 to the rear of the main church on East 12th, an 1847 building that had been acquired that same year.
When Webster Hall, from the first a concert and entertainment venue possessing a liquor license, was built next door in 1886, pastor Thomas Scott Preston and parishioners set up a hue and cry hoping to close it, and some newspaper editorials agreed:
“A place such as this dance hall draws to it and about it characters with whom children should not become familiar, and creates noise and confusion intolerable in the immediate vicinity of a school and church. The proprietor of this establishment deserves no consideration at the hands of the Excise Commissioners, who have full authority, and are under positive obligation to refuse him a license.” NY Sun
However, Webster Hall’s owners got to keep their liquor license. After St. Ann’s parish church closed, the school became the Delehanty Institute; it has now been converted into apartments.
St. Ann’s Church itself, a block north on East 12th, is an even stranger relic. The bell tower is all that remains of the former church at 120 East 12th between 3rd and 2nd Avenues. The church was constructed in 1847, and had been an Anglican church and later a synagogue before it was purchased by St. Ann’s parish in 1870. Retaining the bell tower, architect Napoleon Le Brun demolished most of the existing building and built a new structure.
After a demographic change, the church was re-established as St. Ann’s Armenian Rite Catholic Cathedral, where masses were celebrated in Latin and according to pre-Vatican II rubrics. However, after the Landmarks Preservation Commission failed to landmark the building, it was ultimately sold to NYU, which ripped down the church and built a dormitory, retaining only the original bell tower. “The effect is of a majestic elk, shot and stuffed”, sniffs the AIA Guide to NYC.
According to Christian tradition, St. Anne … usually spelled with an “e,” was the mother of Mary and Jesus Christ’s grandmother: however, her specific name is not mentioned in any of the four Gospels.
As always, “comment…as you see fit.” I earn a small payment when you click on any ad on the site.
8/31/23
4 comments
For some reason I’d come to think it was “hew and cry” Glad to have a chance to look it up. A legal doublet! Null and Void, Cease and Desist, Hue and Cry!
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hue_and_cry
AIA is spot on about the church tower — it’s an impressive mounted trophy
If only we didnt have to wear the uniform with the clip-on little boys
tie those places would have been tolerable,even with nuns.I later
found out that in many southern parochial schools the children didnt
have to wear.uniforms.Remember in The Bells of St. Mary’s?You see
any of those kids wearing uniforms?Thats because Bing Crosby was
cool with that.
.
Very interesting ! My grandfather went to Delahanty’s prior to joining the NYPD. Thanks for the photo also !
A mounted trophy it may be, but, at least it adds a bit of character to the area. If the full church building could have been repurposed, that would have been best, but it was not practical. If it had been completely removed, the resulting new structure would have been flush to the sidewalk with an stark vertical wall of flat glass. That remainder from the past makes that block different from the next block and the next block and the next block. Indeed, we may not be able to save the entire zoo, but the mounted trophies help us remember what those lost animals looked like.