by Kevin Walsh

I was circumnavigating Gramercy Park (a small parcel of a private park between East 20th and 21st Streets and 3rd Avenue and Park Avenue South), preparing for a possible tour or new ForgottenBook Again entry. Mere commoners are not permitted into Gramercy Park. You must be a keyholder at any of the buildings surrounding the park to enter it (and some selected buildings in the area, as we will see). On this early summer day, though, the foliage combined with scaffolding so completely obscured Gramercy’s buildings that I beat a retreat after a cursory walk and headed south on Irving Place.

Irving Place, like nearby Madison Avenue, is named for a historical figure. Unlike Madison, though, the person Irving Place is named for was still among the living at the time, and was at the height of his literary career. Washington Irving (1783-1859), who met his namesake George Washington while a young boy, was popular both in the States and in Europe for his essays and fiction, and was the creator of Ichabod Crane, Rip van Winkle, and the tricornered Father Knickerbocker, NYC’s mascot.

Union Square, Irving Place and Gramercy Park, as well as Lexington Avenue, the northern extension of Irving Place north of the park, were laid out and begun by developer Samuel Bulkley Ruggles beginning in 1831. They all were originally part of his property.



[Ruggles] purchased the Gramercy land from former NYC mayor James Duane. Ruggles drained the swampy land, and from the British Trinity’s St. Johns Park, he borrowed the idea of a private park. He gave the new lot owners a key to their own private tax-exempt park or ‘pleasure ground,’ as parks were then called. This enhanced the value of the surrounding land. (Housing was not built around the park until the 1840s.) Ruggles went on to develop Union Square. In 1838, he served one term in the state legislature. He was sponsored for the Canal Board by his friend Governor William H. Seward, and served on it for 18 years. He supported work on the Croton Aqueduct system.

With Edward Curtis, he constructed warehouses on the Atlantic Docks in Brooklyn. This 1851 project was a financial failure, and it ended Ruggles’ real estate career. He was a trustee of Columbia College from 1836 to 1881. As a businessman, he was a director and comptroller of the New York & Erie Railway Company. He was part of the board of directors of the Panama Railway Company in 1849.

In 1862, he was appointed commissioner for the Union Pacific Railroad. Ruggles was a delegate of the United States to the International Monetary Conference at the Paris Exposition of 1866. In 1869, he represented the United States as delegate to the International Statistical Conference at The Hague. Ruggles served as the trustee of the Astor Library. He was the author of numerous reports on transportation, commerce and monetary policy, including ‘Report upon the Finances and Internal Improvements of the State of New York’ (1838) and ‘International Coinage’ (1867). He visited his lifelong friend and associate Peter Cooper regularly until his death. He is buried in Trinity Cemetery. Museum Planet


STUYVESANT FISH HOUSE, Irving Place and Gramercy Park South. This is the second “Stuyvesant Fish” house in the general area: there’s another one on Stuyvesant Street, a few blocks away. The one on Stuyvesant Street was lived in by Nicholas Fish, married to Elizabeth Stuyvesant, hence the hyphen. This one was lived in by family scion Stuyvesant Fish, hence no hyphen. It was built in 1845 and lived in by Fish until 1900, and it was later occupied by famed publicist Benjamin Sonnenberg beginning in 1931.

I’ve always loved the corner apartment building at 81 Irving Place and 123 East 19th — it’s festooned with dozens of terra cotta gnomes. And more gnomes.

For this 14-story apartment house, architect George Pelham, one of New York’s most active apartment-house designers, exploited the requirements of the zoning law to create an exuberant design [in 1929-1930] with dramatic setbacks and a striking rooftop pavilion surrounding the water tower. The building, planned with 107 small apartments, is faced with brick, often laid in intricate patterns to add excitement to the facades. The building is ornamented wth beige terra-cotta detail of a very high quality. Terra-cotta features include columns, balconies, and gargoyles embellished with animal heads, monsters, and other fanciful detail. NYC Architecture

The big-eared one seems to be influenced by cartoonist R.F. Outcault’s 1890s creation, The Yellow Kid.


THE GRAMERCY, Irving Place and East 18th Street. Most of Irving Place’s buildings were originally two to four-story walkup buildings but interspersed are apartment buildinsg, such as this one built in 1899. It has since been converted to luxury apartments.

The building on the left is a new building built in 2009. According to Jim Naureckas’ Songlines, residents of this building have keys to Gramercy Park, which sort of contradicts its exclusivity.


“TWIN CROOK.” As far as I know, this is the only Twin Bishop Crook in NYC, at the SE corner of Irving Place and West 18th Street. In the early 20th Century cast iron era, there was a specialized Twin post made to illuminate two sides of a street at once, and Bishop Crooks were never twinned. After the classic lamps’ comeback in the 1980s, Twin versions of the long-armed Corvington posts became commonplace, and there were even new Twins produced (mainly along West 40th and 42nd streets and 6th Avenue around Bryant Park) and along Central Park West. But this is the only Twin Bishop Crook.

Note also that the sidewalk side of the diffuser bowls are blacked out so harsh light doesn’t enter the buildings facing the lamps, and the two different Bell luminaire styles. On the left is the Bell introduced in the 1980s when castirons made their comeback, while the one on the right matches the older Bell styling of the 1940s.


PETE’S TAVERN, Irving Place and West 18th, NE corner. There are a number of taverns in NYC jostling and vying for the title of the city’s oldest bar. McSorley’s, on East 7th and Cooper Square, claims the title. But there’s also the Bridge Cafe in the Seaport neighborhood. Pete’s Tavern has also joined the battle. It’s all a matter of semantics, as Pete’s is billed as ‘New York’s Oldest Original Bar.’

The building it occupies was built in 1829 and featured a grocery (in previous centuries liquor was sold and consumed in groceries) by 1851, with a more specific saloon called Healy’s in place by 1864. It was operated as a flower shop hiding a speakeasy during Prohibition days, after which Peter “Pete” Belles purchased it, giving the place the famed name. Since the 1950s, an Italian menu has been featured, though traditional bar food like burgers and steaks are sold too.

Before and after Prohibition Pete’s was frequented by literary types such as William Sydney “O. Henry” Porter (as in the old Lion’s Head and White Horse Taverns in Greenwich Village).


The 1910 12-story high-rise across the street from Pete’s illustrates the changes that have come to Irving Place over the years. The space was occupied in the 19th Century by the smaller buildings you see to its left and right.


Besides mixed-use buildings, Irving Place also features purely residential buildings such as this group of stooped buildings constructed in the mid-1840s.


I’m featuring the building at East 17th housing the Casa Mono, or Monkey House, Restaurant becuase it has a hidden Forgotten NY element.

Above the door, notice the metal letters spelling out the address.


IRVING HOUSE, SW corner Irving Place and West 17th. Despite a local legend, there is no evidence that Washington Irving lived here at 122 Irving — although Edgar Irving (reputed by some as his nephew), lived at #120, next door — and had a son who he named Washington. The building was constructed in 1844.

Beginning in 1892, the building was occupied by actress Elsie DeWolfe, who became a prominent interior decorator, and her partner, literary agent Elisabeth Marbury, who jokingly called themselves “The Bachelors.” The story of the Algonquin Round Table, with its collection of writers, actors and wits, is often told — but no so much The Irving House, where The Bachelors invited George Bernard Shaw, Sarah Bernhardt, and Oscar Wilde in for tea, among other luminaries of the times. It’s possible that DeWolfe began the rumor that Irving had lived here.


One of the handsomest historic plaques in town can be found mounted on the building — it even has its own lamp for nighttime illumination. It features Irving in profile, his birth in New Amsterdam, the future NYC in 1783, his death in Tarrytown in 1859, a scene from his collection Bracebridge Hall and depictions of Rip van Winkle and Ichabod Crane.

Its assertion that “This house was once the home of Washington Irving” is all wet, though. At the bottom are the inscriptions “New York, 1934” and “Fecit A. Finta,” indicating the work of Hungarian sculptor Alexander Finta (1881-1958)


WASHINGTON IRVING HIGH SCHOOL, across from the Irving House, was constructed from 1911-1913 as Girls’ Technical High School with C.B.J. Snyder, the premier architect of NYC shools, its primary designer. The insides are like a museum, preserving a generous sampling of furnishings and art.

From my Open House 2005 page, which depicts the interior:

[The interior] features beautiful oak panelling in the lobby and a series of murals, one 1915 series in the lobby by Barry Faulkner, a gift to the city by the Municipal Arts Society depicting scenes from early Manhattan; another from the same year on the back wall of the auditorium by illustrator Robert Knight Ryland depicting Dutch and Indians trading; a 1932 series in the front of the auditorium of female figures resembling the Greek Muses by J. Mortimer Lichtenauer; and a 1932 series on the staircases depicting old and new Manhattan by Salvatore Lascari.


Friedrich Beer sculpted this bust of Irving, which was originally installed in Bryant Park in 1885 and moved here to Irving High in 1935.



scott August 17, 2012 - 6:23 am

Would those be considered “gnomes,” or are they “gargoyles”?

BTW, we have access to Gramercy Park (though membership in the National Arts Club) if you ever want to go inside.

Jimmy August 1, 2018 - 7:06 am

I think gargoyles must technically be drainspouts.

Dave August 17, 2012 - 7:27 am

You left out The Players Club founded by Edwin Booth who also lived there in that beautiful mansion at 16 Grammercy Park.

Kevin Walsh August 17, 2012 - 11:36 am

That’s coming when I do a Gramercy Park feature.

Michael August 17, 2012 - 9:06 am

I believe that there is public access to Gramercy Park one day a year (Christmas eve?).

Tal Barzilai August 17, 2012 - 4:16 pm

Where exactly did Washington Irving live on what’s now Irving Place assuming he did live there at one point? BTW, he is also known in Sleepy Hollow, located in Westchester County for writing the Headless Horsmen of Sleepy Hollow, and there is a place there dedicated to him. Other than that, I never did understand why Gramercy Park was into a private park. Nevertheless, I am surprised that Block Beautiful wasn’t shown on this page. On a side note, I did go to Pete’s Tavern back in December as part of the Rebuilder’s Holiday Party, which is for having the Twin Towers rebuilt and it was held there.

Kevin Walsh August 17, 2012 - 11:37 pm

Irving never lived on Irving Place. There’s a link to my 19th St page, which does show Block Beautiful.

Loretta Cox December 23, 2018 - 1:00 pm

Kevin, In 1974 I moved in with my soon to be husband at the top floor of 10 Gramercy Park South. Robert Henri the painter had once lived there. As many of the painters of the Ash Can School.
We were renters, and as so, at that time we received a key to the Park.

Marilyn Laws June 21, 2022 - 5:37 am

In the UK those “gnomes/gargoyles” would be referred to, usually, as grotesques. Gargoyles are grotesquely carved spouts.
I used to work on Irving Place, summer job, at Con Ed.
What happened to that building?

Tal Barzilai August 19, 2012 - 2:09 pm

I find it very weird that they named it after him despite having know history living there. I always thought that the bust had something to do with him living there, but I guess not. Then again, there are probably a lot of other cities besides NYC to have streets named after people who never had any history of living or working there. It’s not like James Madison had any history on what’s now Madison Avenue or Madison Street either. Seeing that the street was named during his time, my guess that the origin if giving that street its name is sort of unknown to why it got named in his honor despite not being there at any point in his life.

Nicole August 17, 2012 - 7:38 pm

I worked on and off at Gramercy Park Hotel for years & shamefully never took the opportunity to enter the park.

chris August 19, 2012 - 10:28 pm

I heard washington irving started a club for descendants of dutch families called the st.nicholas club which is still around but you better be pretty well heeled and hoity-toity to join which automatically excludes me and probably groucho marx as……

Tal Barzilai August 20, 2012 - 9:44 pm

I just want to clear this up, did Washington Irving really have any history on this street at any point in his life or was it just named after him in his honor after being randomly picked for him?

Kevin Walsh August 21, 2012 - 6:40 pm

He never lived on the street. When a friend of his built the street, he named it in his honor.

Ramblin' Pete August 21, 2012 - 12:11 pm

Back in the the ’80s, The bust of Irving was featured each week in the opening credit sequence of the ABC sitcom “Head of the Class.” Having grown up right around the corner, I can remember thinking that the diverse group of gifted and talented mixed-gender students on the show certainly didn’t attend Washington Irving High School, but of course the millions of Americans watching out there in TV-land would be certainly none the wiser…

Chee Ef August 29, 2012 - 12:55 pm

My first apartment in NY after college was on GPS in the old Irving House next to the temple. Our super (Billy) – or so the story went – was later jailed for splitting up the one cable TV feed to ALL the units and charging fees to each apartment. But at least he shared the one key to the park just as equitably.

Susan January 7, 2015 - 5:39 pm

Love the site. Tiny correction, though. Yes, Irving Place has “purely residential buildings” on it, but the stooped buildings pictured above that observation aren’t among them. Those buildings house the Inn at Irving Place as well as a tea room, a bar, and a raw-food restaurant.

Michael Kaplan August 6, 2015 - 12:01 pm

Love your site, its a true NYC gem. Just have one minor correction being a long time Gramercy resident, Petes Tavern and Washington Irving’s home are on East 18 and East 17th streets respectfully. Other then that, thank you for all the great background and history, love reading about the neighborhood.

J B lynch October 28, 2015 - 8:40 pm

Hello. I am in possession of a Terracotta Gargoyle that was made in 1927. It is the exactly replica of the one that is on the building at 81 Irving Pl. N.Y.C. Apparently they made some spare statues that they never used. The architect was George F. Pelham 1857 to 1937 he used Gargoyles in his design of this building. I am will to sell this unique .Architectural Antique. It is stored in my yard‏ and covered to protect it from the elements. I am considering moving in the future and would like a new home for this piece of history.
Thank You

FINLEY January 30, 2016 - 1:50 pm

Hello! Wondering if you have any pictures or information on “the Truesdale Family” who lived at 26 east South St.? My Mother came from Ireland and worked for them until the depression. She is gone now and my Son lives in NYC. I would love to find out something about them.

Thanks for your site!

Misch Brannock February 24, 2016 - 12:56 pm

I went to SVA in the 70’s and my friend had a suite (sounds grand but wasn’t) at the Hotel Irving…
we spent many an afternoon between classes here..
There was a fantastic chinese restaurant on about 16th street (not The Cottage)

Shannon Williams July 9, 2017 - 12:26 am

As told by my Great Aunt Berths, my Great, great Grandfather Florecio Betancourt’s Aunt was head Mistress at the Washington Irvibg School for girls. Late 1890’s to 1900’s. Any information conforming this is welcome.

Michael Klaber January 28, 2019 - 10:13 pm

Where was the old opera placed on Irving place? Does anyone have a picture? It was the New York opera before Metropolitan opera House

Virginia Hoffmann January 3, 2020 - 7:23 am

Thank you for the historical tour down my block. I never knew most of the history! Oscar Wilde visiter a block away! I knew about O Henry of course, being a frequent visitor to Petes, where there is a booth where he wrote “The Gift of the Magi”. Yes, Gramercy Park is open for an hour of caroling on Christmas Eve. One thing, all of the cross streets you mention should be “East” not “West”.

Mary DeLara March 21, 2020 - 2:11 pm

I’m reading this years after the article was posted. My
maternal great-grandmother lived at 44 Irving Place (where the high school is located) from her early childhood until after her marriage. There was a boardinghouse at that address that was run by her adoptive mothers, two unmarried sisters.

Marianne January 19, 2021 - 12:29 pm

I just came across your great tour of the area. My mother is 100 yrs old and she has been saying for years that when she was younger, (before WWII) once a year they would hold a big dance at 18 Irving Place for people of Albanese/Arbereshe decent. They were mostly immigrants from the town of San Costantino Albanese, in Southern Italy. At this dance they would have music and dancing all day and collect money for the people in their hometown to help support their annual festival of Maria della Stella (their church of the Blessed Mother). Families from NJ, Breooklyn, and NYC would all be happy to go to this event and donate whatever money they had at the time. Do you know anything about this? and is the original building still there?


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.